Who comes next? The Succession Problem Clubs Can't Ignore
16 November 2026
|
Circular 26-077 Relevant for member clubs |
There is an issue that has been rattling around in my mind for some time, and I genuinely believe it will become one of the biggest governance challenges facing clubs over the coming years: who comes next?
At National Office, we are increasingly hearing from clubs struggling to attract enough nominations to fill positions at upcoming elections.
We have Presidents, Vice Presidents and committee members who have given years, sometimes decades, of service. They are tired. They have given everything they can reasonably give and understandably want to step back, enjoy their club and let somebody else take a turn.
The problem is that increasingly, there isn't always somebody else waiting.
Gone are the days when clubs could simply put the nomination forms on the noticeboard and expect people to line up. People are time poor. Volunteering has changed. Work and family commitments have changed. And the willingness to commit to three, five or ten years around a committee table is not what it once was.
That means succession planning can no longer be something we leave to chance.
Putting out the nomination form isn't succession planning
Most club constitutions set out a clear process for nominations and elections. Of course that process must be followed. But complying with the constitution is not the same thing as actively planning for the future leadership of your club.
If nominations open and the committee suddenly discovers there aren't enough people willing to fill the vacant positions, I would argue the problem started well before nominations opened.
Current committees have a responsibility to be thinking about what comes next.
That doesn't mean choosing the next committee. Elections are ultimately in the hands of the membership and there will always be an element of unpredictability. Somebody you weren't expecting may put their hand up, and the members may decide they are exactly who they want. That doesn't mean however, that the current committee shouldn't be actively developing people who might be willing and capable of standing.
Is anybody actually waiting in the wings?
Succession should be a regular conversation around the committee table.
Who is likely to finish over the next 12 to 18 months? Who might be ready to take another step? What skills are we going to lose when somebody leaves? Where are the gaps around our table now?
And importantly, are the traditional progression pathways actually working?
The obvious example is the Vice President role.
Historically, that role has often provided a natural pathway into the presidency. Yet we regularly speak with Vice Presidents who, when you ask whether they would consider becoming President, emphatically respond: “Oh God, no.”
There is nothing wrong with somebody not wanting the top job. But if the committee has assumed for three years that the Vice President will eventually take over without anyone actually having the conversation, that isn't succession planning. It's hoping.
Ask people
One of the simplest things clubs can do is actively encourage suitable members to consider standing.
Look at the skills around your committee table and ask what would strengthen it. Perhaps you need somebody with financial knowledge, technology experience, marketing skills, legal knowledge, people leadership or simply a different perspective.
Then look around your membership.
Who has those skills? Who contributes positively? Who cares about the club? Who might never consider standing unless somebody actually approached them and said, “Have you ever thought about joining the committee? I think you could make a real contribution.”
Shoulder tapping sometimes gets viewed negatively, as though it is somehow trying to manufacture an election outcome. I don't see it that way.
Encouraging good people to participate in the governance of their club is healthy. They still need to be nominated. They still need to put themselves in front of the members. And ultimately the members still decide.
Make it easier to say yes
We also need to ask whether we do enough to explain what people are actually putting their hands up for.
Instead of simply posting nomination forms, why not hold a short nomination information evening before nominations open?
Explain the different roles. Talk honestly about the time commitment. Explain how meetings operate, what responsibilities committee members have and what support and training is available.
Give interested members the opportunity to ask questions before they put their names forward.
We also need to think about the pathways that sit before committee membership as well. Subcommittees, sports sections, working groups, event committees and short-term projects can all give members an opportunity to become involved without immediately committing themselves to governing the entire club.
That's where future committee members can emerge.
And perhaps the committee itself needs to change
If your club continually struggles to fill ten committee positions, it may also be worth asking a more fundamental question: Do we still need ten?
Many governance structures exist because that's how the club has always done it, rather than because that's what the club needs today.
Subject to your constitution and the requirements applying to your club, a smaller, engaged and capable committee can be far more effective than a larger committee carrying vacancies or filling seats simply because somebody needs to put their name down.
Succession planning shouldn't just ask who will fill the existing positions?
Sometimes it should ask whether the existing structure is still right.
Leaving well is part of serving well
I have enormous respect for people who have given years of voluntary service to their clubs. Nobody should be expected to stay forever, and nobody should feel guilty about deciding that their time is up.
But I do think there is a responsibility that comes with leadership.
If you know you are coming towards the end of your time as President, Chair or committee member, part of finishing well is helping ensure the club remains in capable hands after you leave.
You can't guarantee who members will elect. You can't manufacture volunteers. But you can start conversations. You can identify potential. You can encourage people. You can create pathways. You can share what you have learned. And you can make sure the first time your club thinks seriously about its next President isn't when nominations close with nobody standing.
For me, succession planning needs to become a normal part of club governance. Not once a year. Not two weeks before the AGM. All the time.
Because eventually every good President, every good committee member and every long-serving club stalwart has to step aside.
The question is whether we've done enough to make sure somebody is ready to step forward.